March 24, 2023

Pegasus Voyage

Study the Competition

Medicare Advantage, consolidation drove healthcare insurer trends in 2021

Picture: FG Trade/Getty Images

It was tough to forecast development strains for the payer and health insurance policies industry in 2021, largely simply because of persistent uncertainties owing to the COVID-19 pandemic. Purchaser actions has become a lot more unpredictable, care models and offerings are switching and payers are adapting to a world that’s evolving rapidly and in unpredicted ways.

One variable that has been rendered very unpredictable by the virus is the money health of the nation’s significant insurers, which soared all through the initial waves of the pandemic in 2020 but then settled again down to earth towards the close of that calendar year. In 2021, insurers still posted typically considerable gains, but they have been considerably from the heights viewed the former calendar year.

About the system of the calendar year a few common themes commenced to emerge. Insurers are plowing ahead with electronic transformation initiatives, including the growth of telehealth and digital health. Artificial intelligence and machine understanding have worked their way into the blend and fifty percent of payers now have innovation labs in the belief that electronic innovation will be the key to the foreseeable future.

Insurers also ongoing to consolidate in 2021, ensuing in highly concentrated marketplaces that have drawn the focus of the federal government, which seeks to suppress consolidation in a bid to empower consumers.

And then you can find Medicare Benefit, which continues to mature it is approximated MA plans will cover a lot more people today in 2022 than primary Medicare. Quite a few significant insurers have taken discover, increasing their MA offerings in an effort to capture a lot more of the sector.

It is been a wildly diverse calendar year in the payer area, but the way it has performed out implies a lot of of these development strains could continue on into 2022 … and outside of.


COVID-19 continues to have an affect on each facet of American everyday living and the healthcare industry, and it is driving trends in the payer world as perfectly. At the HIMSS State of Healthcare function in June, Shreesh Tiwari, principal at ZS, mentioned the coronavirus has led to an boost in payer adoption of technological know-how and innovation.

Sixty-four p.c of health insurance policies executives report an accelerated adoption of electronic health initiatives such as digital health. One more fifty three% report an acceleration in adoption of synthetic intelligence and machine understanding procedures, even though forty two% mentioned COVID-19 has assisted aid the adoption of price-based care preparations, in accordance to State of Healthcare study by HIMSS, the mother or father firm of Healthcare Finance Information.

COVID-19 has assisted to generate variations not just in technological know-how, but in frame of mind, Tiwari mentioned. The psychological and cultural barriers in terms of adoption are no more time remaining viewed as troubles.

All around fifty percent of payers have an innovation lab and believe AI and machine understanding will generate innovation ahead. But fifty three% believe healthcare startups will lead the way in driving significant technological know-how innovation, Tiwari mentioned.

The government also performs a key part. Forty-six p.c of payers feel current policies and polices will aid innovation.

“Payers have tasted the fruits of innovation in the earlier few months,” Tiwari mentioned at the time. “Interoperability is remaining viewed as a key driver in terms of running troubles coming out of the technological know-how infrastructure, details infrastructure troubles we have, intently adopted by details privateness and details security.”

Not all of insurers’ electronic efforts are going flawlessly, however. Wellbeing plans are revamping their electronic offerings in a bid to make sure you consumers, but these efforts are intricate, a Deloitte study uncovered in June. Many plans are battling to properly prioritize tasks, suggesting a lack of distinct eyesight.

In reality, about fifty percent of the 35 technological know-how leaders surveyed recognized this lack of eyesight as an impediment to these ongoing electronic transformation initiatives. 

Individuals are the kinds largely afflicted, as consumer-facing platforms have produced the least progress. A very little above fifty percent of respondents, fifty seven%, mentioned they are still in the method of advancing these packages, even though the remainder have not but commenced but say they’ll do so in the subsequent two decades.

There are other places that are lagging as perfectly. The study focused on modernization efforts of 5 technological know-how platforms – administrative, analytics, scientific, main, purchaser assistance and engagement – and only two respondents mentioned they had modernized one particular of those people platforms.

Individuals surveyed recognized cyber and data security as the variety two financial investment precedence soon after business enterprise intelligence. But they warned it could be costly to right cyber-connected mistakes, especially kinds obtaining to do with cloud configuration. Baking in cybersecurity in DevOps from the outset could make for a a lot more productive and resilient method.

The conclusions speak to the broader trouble of patient engagement, which has been an ongoing difficulty for health plans and insurers. A J.D. Energy 2020 U.S. Commercial Member Wellbeing Strategy review uncovered that sixty% of privately insured U.S. health strategy associates mentioned they had not been contacted by their health strategy with steerage or data connected to COVID-19, and approximately fifty percent (48%) mentioned their health strategy has not proven concern for their health considering that the pandemic commenced.

Wellbeing plans have not gained purchaser centricity, as just 36% of professional health strategy associates mentioned their health strategy acts in their ideal curiosity “normally” or “most of the time,” and just twenty five% mentioned they watch their health strategy as a trustworthy partner in their health and wellness.

This lack of purchaser-centric positioning resulted in an all round gratification score past calendar year for professional health plans of 719 on a one,000-level scale, amongst the most affordable of all industries evaluated, in accordance to J.D. Energy.


Medicare Benefit enrollment ongoing to boost and several significant insurers expanded their MA footprints. It is become a scorching sector for insurers heading into the new calendar year.

The Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Services mentioned that in 2022, MA is projected to reach 29.5 million people today compared to 26.nine million enrolled in a Medicare Benefit strategy in 2021. 

For a lot of seniors, MA is the chosen health insurance policies simply because of its reduced upfront month to month fees and included rewards. Medicare Benefit plans will continue on to give a large selection of supplemental rewards in 2022, including eyewear, listening to aids, both of those preventive and detailed dental rewards, accessibility to foods (for a confined length), above-the-counter goods, conditioning rewards and globally unexpected emergency/urgent protection. 

In addition, the share of plans offering specific supplemental rewards for chronically ill men and women will boost from 19% to twenty five%.

An increasing variety of Medicare Benefit twin suitable specific needs plans cover both of those Medicare and Medicaid services for people today who are dually suitable. In 2022, 295 plans (compared to 256 in 2021), will cover all Medicare services, as well as Medicaid-coated behavioral health therapy or extended-term services.

CMS will continue on to check the Part D Senior Price savings Model for insulin for seniors in a lot more than two,100 plans in 2022. This calendar year, above five hundred new Medicare Benefit and Part D prescription drug plans, as perfectly as two new pharmaceutical producers of insulin, are joining the product that lowers out-of-pocket paying out.

In addition, a lot more than one,000 Medicare Benefit plans will take part in the CMS Innovation Center’s Medicare Benefit Benefit-Primarily based Insurance policies Layout Model in 2022, which checks the effect of offering a projected 3.7 million people today tailored rewards made to much better control their conditions and handle social needs from foods insecurity to social isolation. 

The VBID Model’s Hospice Profit Ingredient, now in its next calendar year, will also be provided by 115 Medicare Benefit plans in parts of 22 states and U.S. territories. It delivers enrollees enhanced accessibility to palliative and built-in hospice care. 

To support with their Medicare fees, reduced-earnings seniors and grown ups with disabilities could qualify to obtain money guidance from the Medicare Price savings Packages. Only about fifty percent of suitable people today are enrolled, CMS mentioned.

Cigna is receiving on on the act by increasing its MA plans, escalating into 108 new counties and three new states – Connecticut, Oregon and Washington – which will boost its geographic existence by approximately thirty%, the insurance provider mentioned in Oct.

As component of the growth, Cigna mentioned most current consumers will pay back the same or decreased rates, and promised that each sector will have at least one particular $ quality strategy. Other rewards will incorporate a social link software to combat loneliness, tailored plans for people today with diabetes and incentives for once-a-year wellness tests and other preventive care.

Cigna has enhanced its geographic existence in MA by 80% considering that 2019, the insurance provider mentioned. The firm now delivers plans in 477 counties throughout 26 states and the District of Columbia.

Centene, meanwhile, mentioned this calendar year it will be broadening its reach in the Medicare Benefit area in 2022, increasing into 327 new counties and three new states: Massachusetts, Nebraska and Oklahoma.

In all, this signifies a 26% growth of Centene’s MA footprint, with the offering offered to a opportunity 48 million beneficiaries throughout 36 states. At this time, Centene serves a lot more than million MA associates throughout 33 states.

In September, Centene also introduced it would consolidate its current Medicare makes, including Allwell, Wellbeing Web, Fidelis Care, Trillium Benefit, ‘Ohana Wellbeing Strategy and TexanPlus, underneath one particular unified model dubbed Wellcare.

Meanwhile, UnitedHealthcare, which currently has major sector handle with its Medicare Benefit plans, will improve its foothold in the area by increasing its MA plans in 2022, introducing a opportunity million associates and achieving ninety four% of Medicare-suitable consumers in the U.S.

At this time, a lot more than 7.3 million people today are currently enrolled in UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Benefit plans. The insurance provider mentioned the growth will focus on decreasing prescription drug fees, and strengthening rewards and the member working experience.

But even though UnitedHealthcare has a enormous foothold in the Medicare Benefit area, it underwent scrutiny from the federal government earlier this month, when the Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Services blocked four Medicare Benefit plans from enrolling new associates in 2022 simply because they failed to shell out the minimum threshold on healthcare rewards. Three UnitedHealthcare plans and one particular Anthem strategy failed to hit the expected 85% mark three decades in a row.

Medicare Benefit plans are expected to shell out a minimum of 85% of quality bucks on healthcare costs failure to do so for three consecutive decades triggers the sanctions.

For UHC, the penalties implement to its MA plans in Arkansas, New Mexico and the Midwest, which encompasses Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska and Iowa. UHC plans cover about eighty three,000 associates, and the Anthem strategy covers about one,two hundred associates. They can not give choose plans to associates till 2023, assuming they hit the 85% threshold subsequent calendar year – what is referred to as the healthcare reduction ratio (MLR). If they fall short to hit the threshold for 5 decades in a row, the government will terminate the contracts.

UHC representatives told Bloomberg that it skipped the 85% benchmark in selected marketplaces in component simply because of individuals deferring healthcare care owing to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Humana also introduced it would debut a new Medicare Benefit PPO strategy in 37 rural counties in North Carolina in reaction to sector need in the jap component of the state. 


Wellbeing insurance provider consolidation has been yet another ongoing development – and one particular the current administration would like to see with tighter reigns.

An government get issued by President Joe Biden in July cracked down on healthcare facility and health insurance policies consolidations and other steps it mentioned decreases competition and drives up price ranges. The four places of healthcare targeted are: prescription medicines, healthcare facility consolidation, health insurance policies consolidations and listening to aids.

Consolidation in the health insurance policies industry has intended that a lot of consumers have very little alternative when it will come to picking insurers, the get mentioned. 

Biden directed the Office of Wellbeing and Human Services to standardize strategy selections in the health insurance policies marketplace so people today can comparison store a lot more effortlessly. Programs provided on the exchanges are intricate by the numerous services provided and distinctions in deductibles, the get mentioned.

Rick Pollack, president and CEO of the American Medical center Association, urged federal businesses at the time to focus on policies that handle competition amongst professional health insurers.

“In reality, with professional health insurance policies plans, approximately three out of four marketplaces have been highly concentrated in 2019 and the major 5 greatest insurers by yourself handle approximately 50% of the sector. Reports have uncovered that when an insurance policies sector is highly concentrated, insurers decrease service provider payments and do not pass cost savings together to the consumer.”

The outcomes of consolidation in 2021 also prolonged to prescription medicines. Consolidation amongst standalone Medicare Part D prescription drug plans was the root cause of a 23% drop in offerings for 2022, in accordance to conclusions published past month by the Kaiser Relatives Basis.

The regular Medicare beneficiary will have a alternative of 23 stand-by yourself prescription drug plans (PDPs) in 2022, seven less PDP selections than in 2021, the details showed. Although the variety of PDP selections in 2022 is considerably decreased than the peak in 2007 – when there have been fifty six such selections, on regular – there are still a lot of standalone drug strategy selections, in accordance to KFF.

The comparatively massive reduce in the variety of PDPs for 2022 is largely the consequence of consolidations of strategy offerings sponsored by Cigna and Centene, ensuing in the sector exit of three nationwide PDPs from just about every organization in just about every location: all three of Cigna’s Express Scripts PDPs and three of Centene’s six Wellcare PDPs. Part D sponsors are confined to offering no a lot more than three PDPs in just about every location. 

This accounts for just above two hundred PDPs provided in 2021 that will no more time be provided in 2022. Enrollees in these consolidated plans will be instantly switched to other plans provided by the same strategy sponsor, even though they can opt for to swap into a diverse strategy all through the once-a-year open up enrollment time period.

The variety of companies sponsoring stand-by yourself drug plans has declined steadily above time, from a lot more than forty companies in 2010 and earlier decades, dropping beneath twenty five companies commencing in 2015, and at sixteen companies in 2022. That is decreased than in any other calendar year considering that Part D commenced. 

PDP enrollment is expected to be concentrated in a smaller variety of companies in 2022, as it has been each calendar year. Primarily based on August 2021 enrollment, eight out of ten enrollees in 2022 are projected to be in PDPs operated by just four companies: CVS Wellbeing, Centene, UnitedHealth and Humana. All four companies give PDPs in all 34 regions subsequent calendar year.

Despite these calendar year-to-calendar year variations in strategy protection and fees, as perfectly as variations in beneficiaries’ health needs, a former KFF evaluation uncovered that most Medicare beneficiaries did not examine plans all through a latest open up enrollment time period, and most Part D enrollees did not examine the protection provided by their drug strategy to other drug plans.

The figures are equivalent throughout both of those Medicare Benefit and traditional Medicare, with 68% of MA beneficiaries expressing they will not examine healthcare plans, and seventy three% of those people in traditional Medicare proclaiming the same.

Twitter: @JELagasse
E mail the writer: [email protected]